Why We Are Speaking Out

Zohran Mamdani has publicly engaged with Jewish communities and does not appear to personally hate Jews. However, we believe his approach to Israel, Zionism, and anti-Israel activism has been deeply flawed and dangerous.

Words matter — especially from people in positions of power.

Freedom of speech is one of the core values of the United States, and every American has the right to criticize governments and political movements. But when public officials or political leaders repeatedly promote rhetoric that targets Zionism while dismissing the concerns of Jewish communities, the consequences can extend far beyond political debate.

For millions of Jews around the world, Zionism is not an abstract political idea — it is tied to Jewish identity, safety, and self-determination. We believe that when anti-Zionist rhetoric demonizes or isolates Zionists entirely, it can fuel antisemitism, normalize hostility toward Jews, and contribute to a climate where Jewish New Yorkers feel unsafe.

Silence is not an option.

Leaders must be held accountable for the environments they help create, the movements they amplify, and the standards they set for public discourse.